Music Video or Art Film?

Just before Christmas I filmed and edited a short promo video for an artist by the name of Gigo. The idea was to do a short version of a music video that he could use in promotion for his single release. I came up with the idea of a lost girl running and dancing in the forest. So that is what we did and the result can be seen further down. In the music video I built a short story with her and the singer and edited it for social media. I however loved the footage so much so I also made what maybe can be called an art video(?) with a completely new story. What do you guys think about them?

Here is the music video:

And here my own version:

Which is better?